Skip to content

ICH

ICH Q9(R1) 5.2

Risk-Based Decision-Making

5. RISK MANAGEMENT METHODOLOGY

Section text

Risk-based decision-making is inherent in all quality risk management activities; it provides an essential foundation for decision makers in an organization. Effective risk-based decision-making begins with determining the level of effort, formality and documentation that should be applied during the quality risk management process. The decisions made from quality risk management activities include those in relation to what hazards exist, the risks associated with those hazards, the risk controls required, the acceptability of the residual risk after risk controls, and also the communication and review of quality risk management activities and outputs.

As all decision-making relies on the use of knowledge, see ICH Q10 for guidance in relation to knowledge management. It is important also to ensure the integrity of the data that are used for risk-based decision-making.

Approaches to risk-based decision-making:

There are different processes that may be used to make risk-based decisions; these are directly related to the level of formality that is applied during the quality risk management process. (See Section 5.1 above for guidance on what constitutes formality in quality risk management.)

Higher levels of formality in quality risk management may require higher levels of structure in relation to risk-based decision-making. There can be varying degrees of structure with regard to approaches for risk-based decision-making. These degrees of structure can be considered to be on a continuum (or spectrum). Below are descriptions of highly structured vs. less structured processes, and for rule-based processes when making risk-based decisions:

• Some risk-based decision-making processes are highly structured and can involve a formal analysis of the available options that exist before making a decision. They involve an in- depth consideration of relevant factors associated with the available options. Such processes might be used when there is a high degree of importance associated with the decision, and when the level of uncertainty and/or complexity is high.

• Other risk-based decision-making processes are less structured; here, simpler approaches are used to arrive at decisions, and they primarily make use of existing knowledge to support an assessment of hazards, risks and any required risk controls. Such processes might still be used when there is a high degree of importance associated with the decision, but the degree of uncertainty and/or complexity is lower.

• Decisions might also be made using rule-based (or standardized) approaches, which do not require a new risk assessment to make such decisions. This is where there are SOPs, policies or well understood requirements in place which determine what decisions must be made. Here, rules (or limits) may be in place which govern such decisions; these may be based on a previously obtained understanding of the relevant risks and they usually lead to predetermined actions and/or expected outcomes.

The above approaches to risk-based decision-making are beneficial because they address uncertainty through the use of knowledge, facilitating informed decisions by regulators and the pharmaceutical industry in a multitude of areas. They also help recognize where uncertainty remains, so that appropriate risk controls (including improved detection) may be identified to enhance understanding of those variables and further reduce the level of uncertainty.

Glossary terms that cite this clause

Source: International Council for Harmonisation (ICH) · © ICH. Per the legal notice in each guideline, the document may be used, reproduced and distributed provided ICH's copyright is acknowledged; any adaptation or translation must be labelled as such and must not imply ICH endorsement. · retrieved 2026-11-15

Weekly Newsletter

Get new findings like these every Monday

Every Monday we email the week's new findings and actions from the FDA, EMA, Health Canada and MFDS. Each one links to its record on our site, where you'll find the regulator's original document. We'll also let you know when the site gains new features. Unsubscribe any time with one click.

See recent findings first

Sent every Monday · a confirmation email follows when you subscribe · unsubscribe from the footer of any email.