ICH
ICH Q9(R1) 5.1
Formality in Quality Risk Management
5. RISK MANAGEMENT METHODOLOGY
조항 원문
Formality in quality risk management is not a binary concept (i.e. formal/informal); varying degrees of formality may be applied during quality risk management activities, including when making risk-based decisions. In this way, formality can be considered a continuum (or spectrum), ranging from low to high.
When determining how much formality to apply to a given quality risk management activity, certain factors may be considered. These may include, for example, the following:
• Uncertainty: The term “uncertainty” in quality risk management means lack of knowledge about hazards, harms and, consequently, their associated risks. The level of uncertainty that is associated with the area being risk assessed informs how much formality may be required to manage potential risks. Systematic approaches for acquiring, analysing, storing and disseminating scientific information are essential for generating knowledge, which in turn informs all quality risk management activities. Uncertainty may be reduced via effective knowledge management, which enables accumulated and new information (both internal and external) to be used to support risk-based decisions throughout the product lifecycle.
• Importance: The more important a risk-based decision may be in relation to product quality, the higher the level of formality that should be applied, and the greater the need to reduce the level of uncertainty associated with it.
• Complexity: The more complex a process or subject area is to a quality risk management activity, the higher the level of formality that should be applied to assure product quality.
Higher levels of uncertainty, importance or complexity may require more formal quality risk management approaches to manage potential risks and to support effective risk-based decision-making.
The overall approach for determining how much formality to apply during quality risk management activities should be described within the quality system. Resource constraints should not be used to justify the use of lower levels of formality in the quality risk management process. Risk scores, ratings and assessments should be based on an appropriate use of evidence, science and knowledge. Regardless of how much formality is applied, the robust management of risk is the goal of the process.
The following may be characteristics of higher levels of formality:
• All parts of the quality risk management process (risk assessment, risk control, risk review and risk communication) are explicitly performed, and stand-alone quality risk management reports or related documents which address all aspects of the process may be generated and are documented (e.g., within the quality system).
• Quality risk management tools, including those shown in Annex 1, are used in some or all parts of the process.
• A cross-functional team is assembled for the quality risk management activity.
• Use of a facilitator, with experience and knowledge of the quality risk management process, may be integral to a higher formality process.
The following may be characteristics of lower levels of formality:
• One or more parts of the quality risk management process are not performed as stand-alone activities but are addressed within other elements of the quality system which may have risk assessment and risk control activities embedded within them.
• Quality risk management tools might not be used in some or all parts of the process.
• A cross-functional team might not be necessary.
• Stand-alone quality risk management reports might not be generated. The outcome of the quality risk management process is usually documented in the relevant parts of the quality system.
Note: As indicated above, degrees of formality between the above higher and lower levels also exist and may be used.
본문은 원문(영어)입니다. 국문 번역은 준비 중입니다.
이 조항을 근거로 든 용어
출처: International Council for Harmonisation (ICH) · © ICH. Per the legal notice in each guideline, the document may be used, reproduced and distributed provided ICH's copyright is acknowledged; any adaptation or translation must be labelled as such and must not imply ICH endorsement. · 수집일 2026-11-15